The movie Joker (2019) Todd Phillips is certainly very good and impressive. And very sad. Especially if you watch it alone. Among other unfamiliar and possibly lonely people in the audience. Probably there were some. The stunning Joaquin Phoenix demonstrated his high-class acting skills and genuine reincarnation. He’s like Christian Bale in the Machinist – exhausted, slouched, stuck out his shoulder blade. And this scar on the upper lip corresponds to the image.
His Arthur Fleck is so sickly and unhealthy, but you can see that at the same time physically he can be very strong. With mental problems in general, I read somewhere that it would be better for you to have a healthy bully than a crazy drysch with a screwdriver. Flek runs very fast, there is something in him from an insect, no one has caught up with him in the whole movie.
And this dance on the stairs, such crazy charm and unhealthy dizzying beauty, is when in musicals the hero goes down the steps. And then he’s dancing and smoking, and two detectives are watching this action from above. Probably that music wasn’t playing in their heads. Sinatra sang New York, and Gotham City is New York, and the metropolis is like a separate character. As Limonov recalled, one day in 1977 New York was overtaken by a blackout, the city was plunged into darkness, there was no electricity for more than a day, thousands of shops were looted. The then chief of police said that New York would not survive a second such night. This is such a ghostly civilization, it is enough to turn off the lights and water, as people will quickly lose their human appearance. Once I watched the movie “High-rise”, it’s just about that. One hope for Batman.
I am very sorry for Arthur Fleck as a person. His life was hard and oh how unsweetened. As a child, he was beaten and bullied, and with the connivance of his crazy mother. She didn’t think much of it. It is strange, of course, that in general they left her a son in her deranged state. After all, you can’t even imagine how easy it is to commit physical violence against a child, what a fine line it is, how easy it is to cross. If you start, it is very difficult to stop. The child is weak and cannot fight back, he is absolutely defenseless. A parent can slide into a very dark abyss. And someone may never forgive someone.
At 40+, Arthur is in many ways like a child, he is naive, fragile, simple, eccentric. The freak is not of this world. This is often the case with people who live with their mother all their lives. The mother manipulates, inspires that you are still a child and simply does not let you grow up. She takes care of even if she doesn’t do anything herself anymore, and she can’t do anything. At the beginning of the film, there is still no anger and hatred in Arthur. Only sadness, confusion, disappointment in a cruel world, thoughts of death. “It’s better if I’m gone.” In the film, we see the transformation of Arthur Fleck into the Joker, who discarded goodness and morality, proclaiming chaos as his life credo.
Of the controversial moments, the episode where Arthur and the boy, the son of a mayoral candidate, is how Fleck lures him to himself. Why is he, Bruce Wayne, so trusting and careless? It is unclear. Yes, and also allows you to put your fingers in your mouth, making a “smile”.
The jokes in the movie are really good. The Joker has a special sense of humor:
“When I was little and said I was going to be a comedian, everyone laughed at me. And now I’ve grown up, become a comedian and no one is laughing.”
Jokes about death – shoot yourself in the temple or point a gun from below and bang! Or shoot the host live. What could be funnier? Especially after he laughed at you and made you look ridiculous in front of an audience of millions. Is that funny to you now, Murray Franklin?
When I think about having an affair with a Black woman, I think of Kerouac’s “Underground”. And yet it’s a pity that Arthur didn’t have anything with a black girl, everything turned out to be a figment of his sick imagination. She would probably have pulled him out of the abyss, made him normal. Ordinary women do this with men who are different from the rest, from the “normal” average mass. Dreamers, revolutionaries, madmen, adventurers – if they happen to fall in love with an ordinary woman, she will drag him into the world of ordinary people, into family life, where he will wallow in daily worries and forget about his lofty aspirations. Of course, there may not be tranquility here either, but this is a completely different sea, everyday.
The episode with the dwarf is really touching and cute in its own way. And I don’t feel sorry at all for the fat man, allegedly Arthur’s friend, who gave him a gun. This actor played a maniac in “True Detective”, a repulsive character, he got what he deserved here. If the Phoenix hero attracts, despite his madness, then Randall is definitely repulsive, he’s like a pig. He is indirectly to blame for what happened.
Arthur commits murder, yes, three at once, and he likes it. He makes a conscious choice, a step into his dark side. This gives him an incentive, a desire to live. “I was the soul of a sick society.” Uncontrollable fits of laughter gradually go away, and now he laughs deliberately, in a new way. To resist the system, you have to be crazy. Courage alone is not enough to challenge the establishment. The absence of fear of death is not enough, you really have to be crazy. That’s the beauty and freedom of this movie.
The Joker professes anarchy, of course not without reason, everywhere we see the power of rich usurpers over crowds of poor oppressed – this is the modern world. Super-rats, mountains of garbage, riots, uncontrolled violence – these are today’s realities. There are fewer and fewer peaceful places on the planet. It’s like a Bob Dylan song – times are changing. We must be prepared for the worst. I hope that these expectations will remain only expectations. At least for a long time.
The most terrible part of the Joker is that over the decades of its existence, the character has turned into a real monster: absolutely any Joker… It works. Whether it’s a harmless Romero with makeup over a mustache or Summer with tattoos, whether you like it or not, the Joker will always work, in any role. Personally, I will always like Ledger and Phoenix in makeup less than the classic Nicholson, completely white due to forced swimming in a vat of chemical waste, but… That’s what I’m talking about. This is the strongest and weakest feature of the Joker: he doesn’t have to kill someone, he doesn’t have to be crazy, he doesn’t have to follow the canons of his own comic book – he can easily do with ordinary makeup. The Joker has become exactly what he is associated with – a real anarchy from the world of characters. If you write about the Joker, it will work, no matter what you write. Better, worse, someone will like it, someone won’t, but the Joker… It will work.
I don’t think it’s worth saying that I’m a fan of this character. I’ve reviewed everything that has anything to do with the Joker, including the movie The Man Who Laughs ’28. So I have to talk about the film, first of all rejecting this character.
And the film turned out to be a good one. Very beautiful and well made. Todd Phillips mentioned that the Joker was influenced by Martin Scorsese’s film Taxi Driver – and I was very afraid that I would see something boring and completely incomprehensible, since I consider the Taxi Driver to be the most overrated picture by Comrade Scorsese. Fortunately, my fears were not justified. Joker is a great movie.
First, the main character… It’s very good that the article mentioned the Driver – I also immediately noticed how thin the Phoenix is on the screen. It’s even a shame how zealously Phoenix’s body stands out against the background of many other actors in modern films who do not prepare for the role from the word at all. Joaquin obviously prepared and prepared well. And… probably not even worth talking about acting. Everything is perfect, right down to the sound: the original voice acting of the Joker leads to real ecstasy. Very rarely does a character change in voice throughout the film, and this fact also says a lot.
Speaking of sound, if there is a place for this film in the context of our website, it is definitely because of the soundtrack. The film’s OST includes a very solid number of classic jazz compositions, including several tracks performed by Frank Sinatra, as well as the acid White Room performed by Cream and Rock & Roll by Gary Glitter (yes, the same pedophile that Gene Vincent once almost shot).
The plot of the film perfectly shows the formation of the cult of personality, and the personality itself does not really need this cult. Everything looms beautifully by itself. In the context of comics, Joker fans will be interested to see how and where a cult can come from such a personality as the Joker, and why people can follow him voluntarily at all – it seems to me that this topic has never been disclosed in comics. At least not in movies and games… Well, certainly not that deep. Plus, a very interesting point is that in this movie it’s not Batman who creates the Joker, but exactly the opposite: the Joker creates Batman – yes, almost like in the ’89 movie.
Well and… it is interesting to note once again that the noirier, darker and more mature DC makes its film, the better it turns out. I hope one day the studio will finally understand its strong side and stop trying to compete with Disney / Marvel in a foreign field, where they still can’t show anything sensible. I have everything.
Editorial board: a day after writing the comment, I realized that I really wanted to move away from the Joker as a character, but I also didn’t want to talk about this film as a statement about the state of our society – after all, everyone who is not lazy has already said this. As a result, the comment turned out to be extremely awkward, well, to hell with it – let it stay that way. I’ll just say one more thing: from the point of view of a comic book fan, it’s very nice to watch this movie, imagining that it’s the Joker himself telling his story, being an unreliable narrator, like in The Killing Joke. Thus, the film, as it seems to me, leaves behind the greatest number of positive impressions.